a list compiled by Alex Kasman (College of Charleston)
Home  All  New  Browse  Search  About 
... 

... 
This story appeared in the March 2000 issue of Asimov's Science Fiction. A sequel appeared in the same magazine almost three years later. For those who may not know, the BanachTarski Theorem is a real, surprising, and somewhat disturbing theorem of geometry. What it says, essentially, is that any sphere can be broken apart into a finite number of pieces and then reassembled into another sphere of any desired volume. Certainly this is disturbing: one is inclined either to be impressed that mathematics has shown us that volume is not what we think it is, or perhaps one will conclude that mathematics doesn't make sense after all! [See Division by Zero]. When I learned about it as an undergraduate (back in the 20th century) we were told that this was an indication of possible problems with the Axiom of Choice (an axiom of set theory that is not universally popular), but that viewpoint seems to be out of date. This is now seen as just one of many indications that volume is a slipperier topic than one might expect. In particular, as this theorem and others like it show, the notion of volume is not "finitely additive"...and there is no alternative measure for arbitrary sets in dimensions 3 or higher which are! In other words, when it comes to volume, the whole may NOT be equal to the sum of its parts. For more information about this funky theorem, check out this link or even this one. Now, please forgive me for being too serious, but it annoyed me that the story misuses the theorem. If one were to ignore the atomist view of matter, and if one had a way to break matter (even your own body) up into pieces of arbitrary shape, then the BanachTarski theorem WOULD give you a way to reassemble those pieces into something of a different volume. However, this story makes it sound as if it is the theorem that gives them the power to break their body into pieces, and that's just silly. (Sorry.) 
(Note: This is just one work of mathematical fiction from the list. To see the entire list or to see more works of mathematical fiction, return to the Homepage.) 

Home  All  New  Browse  Search  About 
(Maintained by Alex Kasman, College of Charleston)